Post by: Louis Fullenkamp, PT, DPT, SCS, OCS, CSCS, BRM
An exercise has been in the program for six weeks. The athlete knows it well, the loading is familiar, and the training log is starting to look repetitive. Is it time for something new?
The calendar alone cannot answer that question. Before changing a movement, identify what the change should accomplish. A useful variation addresses a training need, a constraint, or a problem with engagement. Novelty by itself does not establish that the program has improved.
What the evidence supports
A 2022 systematic review included eight studies involving 241 young men. The authors concluded that systematic exercise variation may benefit regional muscle growth and strength, while cautioning against excessive or redundant changes.[1] That supports deliberate selection, but it does not establish a universal rotation schedule.
A later randomized trial offers useful perspective. Seventy young women completed ten weeks of lower-body resistance training using either constant exercises or a repeatable schedule of different exercises across the week. Both approaches produced similar improvements in measured thigh muscle thickness and strength.[2] More exercises did not automatically produce more adaptation.
Enjoyment also matters. In an eight-week trial involving 21 resistance-trained men, session-to-session randomized exercises and repetition ranges produced similar measured strength and muscle-thickness outcomes to a fixed program, with improved intrinsic motivation in the varied group.[3] This small, short study does not establish better long-term adherence or prove that randomization is optimal.
Together, these studies support flexibility. They do not show that every movement expires after four weeks, that variation guarantees continued progress, or that consistency requires an identical workout forever. Their findings concern resistance-training adaptations, not a validated return-to-sport decision rule.
Make three decisions: retain, progress, or replace
The framework below is practical inference informed by the evidence, not a research-validated algorithm.
Retain the exercise when it still serves its purpose. If the target quality is improving, the movement is tolerable, and the athlete can perform it consistently, familiarity is useful. Keep recording load, repetitions, range of motion, and effort so that comparisons mean something.
When performance in a specific lift matters, preserve opportunities to practice that lift. A heavier leg press may be useful training, but it does not establish that the athlete’s squat has improved. Test the outcome you actually care about.
Progress the prescription when the movement fits but the challenge needs adjustment. Exercise selection and exercise dose are separate decisions. Adding a repetition, increasing load, adjusting range, or changing the number of sets may solve the problem without replacing the movement. Choose the adjustment that serves the goal; adding sets is not the default.
A disappointing session is not enough evidence of a plateau. Look for a repeated pattern under reasonably comparable conditions. Review attendance, effort, rest intervals, sleep, and competing sport demands before deciding the exercise has stopped working. Sometimes the appropriate progression is better execution. Sometimes the appropriate adjustment is less fatigue.
Replace the exercise when another option better serves the current job. Reasons include unavailable equipment, a loading limitation unrelated to the target muscles, a changed training priority, or a movement that remains poorly tolerated despite appropriate modifications.
In rehabilitation, exercise changes should also reflect the examination, tissue restrictions, and response during and after loading. Switching movements does not resolve the need to understand worsening symptoms.
Engagement can justify a change too. Ask what is becoming difficult to sustain. A choice between two suitable accessories may solve boredom without rebuilding the entire session.
A concrete programming example
Consider a hypothetical healthy recreational athlete using goblet squats to develop lower-body strength.
Start with three sets of six to eight repetitions, approximately two repetitions in reserve, and two to three minutes of rest. Repetitions in reserve means the estimated number of additional repetitions possible before reaching failure.
Use a consistent depth and setup. If the athlete reaches eight repetitions on all three sets at the intended effort, increase the load by the smallest practical increment and return toward six repetitions. If only the first set reaches eight, keep the load and build the remaining sets.
That is a reason to progress, not automatically replace, the exercise.
Now suppose holding the dumbbell repeatedly ends the set before the legs receive the intended challenge. More goblet-squat sets may simply repeat the same limitation. If available and appropriate for the athlete, a leg press could provide a more practical way to load the legs.
That is a reason to replace the exercise because the constraint has changed.
Begin the new movement conservatively, establish a repeatable setup and range, and select its load by effort. Do not convert the goblet-squat load into a supposedly equivalent leg-press load. The exercises require separate baselines.
If learning the squat pattern remains a separate goal, retain a small amount of suitable squat practice. Include it because that goal matters, not because every previous exercise must remain in the program.
Make the change reviewable
Before introducing a variation, write one sentence: “This change should improve _____ because _____.”
Then identify what you will monitor: progression at comparable effort, completion of the intended work, symptom response, or willingness to train. Review the result across repeated exposures. Keep the change if it helps; reconsider it if it adds complexity without solving the problem.
Planned rotation can fit this approach. Use a small, repeatable menu, give each movement a clear role, and compare each variation with its own previous performances.
The Lab Principle
Keep an exercise while it earns its place. Progress its dose when appropriate, and replace it when you can explain what the replacement should do better.
References
- Kassiano W, Nunes JP, Costa B, Ribeiro AS, Schoenfeld BJ, Cyrino ES. Does Varying Resistance Exercises Promote Superior Muscle Hypertrophy and Strength Gains? A Systematic Review. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research. 2022;36(6):1753–1762. https://doi.org/10.1519/JSC.0000000000004258. PubMed
- Kassiano W, Costa B, Kunevaliki G, et al. Muscle Hypertrophy and Strength Adaptations to Systematically Varying Resistance Exercises. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport. 2025;96(2):371–381. Published online 2024. https://doi.org/10.1080/02701367.2024.2409961. PubMed
- Baz-Valle E, Schoenfeld BJ, Torres-Unda J, Santos-Concejero J, Balsalobre-Fernández C. The effects of exercise variation in muscle thickness, maximal strength and motivation in resistance trained men. PLOS ONE. 2019;14(12):e0226989. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0226989. Full text
No comments:
Post a Comment